Ahhhhh, such a cute little thing. Much more cute than Intercessional, I'm sure.
I vote no because:-
Isn't the preferred outcome one where healthy, robust debate can take place without bullying or trolling? A private room does not permit debate and a public room is wide open to nastiness. Surely the ideal outcome is where people treat each other with respect and decency, which isn't going to happen unless the bullies are run out of town.
Sagie's suggestion permits healthy debate yet renders the bullies and trolls impotent. I think that is why they didn't like it.
only one issue with that fictional tale. Shanti, Camden and a good number of others also disagreed and none of them are so called trolls. Nice try, try again